Lampstand Press
Company Tapestry of Grace Community Store

Home » Community » The Forum

Email us! These forums are a great place to get answers to your questions or discuss the content of Tapestry of Grace. Please use the suggestion button (left) to send us your ideas for ways that we can improve this program!
Tapestry of Grace Forums    tapestryofgrace.groupee.net    Tapestry of Grace  Hop To Forum Categories  Year 3 Redesign Topics ONLY  Hop To Forums  Y3 Literature    Shorter Works Appendix question - week 6
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
Reply
  
-star Rating Rate It!  Login/Join 
Posted
I would really appreciate if someone could help this non-literature mother understand the Teacher's Appendix B. On page 2 under the answers for "Meter" it says that "an anapest is substituted for an iamb in lines 6 and 7." It would seem to me that according to the scansion shown that a trochee is substituted for the iamb in lines 6 and 12. I would love if someone could clarify this for me!

I also don't understand the examples of elisions listed in the last paragraph of the answers. I would think the "fluttering" is an example of elision in line 6. Is it? Line 9 only has 8 syllables so how can it contain an elision? Line 13 and 14 also seem to contain only 8 syllables but the answer key lists these lines as having an elision.

Thanks in advance,
Kim
Mom to 10 great kids,
ages 16,14,13,12,10,8,6,4,2,2 weeks
 
Posts: 112 | Registered: 21 March 2006Reply With QuoteReport This Post
Posted Hide Post
Hi Kim! The anapest is, I think, a typo. Sorry about that. :-/ You're right, it should say trochee.

As for the elision marks, I will double-check them also but I want to just let you know---scansion isn't at all an exact science. Different people read sound patterns in slightly different ways, so what you may be seeing with the elision markers is just a difference in reading between our scanners and you.

This doesn't mean that you or we are "right"---there are often two or three different equally viable ways of scanning a poem. However, since our elision marks may also include a typo, I'll go ahead and double-check them.

Hope this helps! Thanks for pointing it out!

Christy Somerville
 
Posts: 393 | Registered: 26 July 2006Reply With QuoteReport This Post
  Powered by Social Strata  
 

Tapestry of Grace Forums    tapestryofgrace.groupee.net    Tapestry of Grace  Hop To Forum Categories  Year 3 Redesign Topics ONLY  Hop To Forums  Y3 Literature    Shorter Works Appendix question - week 6